Sole Society makes fashionable, colourful, comfortable and relatively affordable footwear. Styles cost between $59.95 to $79.95 full price. I bought a pair of silver grey Olyvia ankle strap pumps last year that are extremely comfortable and still going strong. Suede Sole Society shoes are especially comfortable, and forgiving on a higher volume foot. Styles made of textile fabrics are more stiff.
I’ve seen some of these options in person and the ones I haven’t seen have rave reviews online. The vibe is quite ladylike, fashionable, dressy, soft and simple. Nothing hard edge or rugged about these designs. Sizes run from a US 5 to 11. The d’Orsay styles might run half a size big (although they fit me true to size). Sandals might run half a size big for low volume feet.