Unfrumped and JAileen --
Thanks for your candor! I know it can be tough to share a minority viewpoint. I'm mulling! While feeling a small urge to live up to my full name...Vixen.
E --
Thanks! A version with dark hose was suggested by my beloved (who is all "why is there a layer of fabric over the other stuff? why is it all boxy?") and it's on the list to check out! I agree it may help the eeeek factor without my going all the way to leggings.
Citygirldc, Merwoman, AviaMariah, JulieJohn, and Pil --
Thank you; you guys made me smile. Pil, I know, right -- surprisingly versatile to my eye, anyway. And works with regular undergarments, yea! I bought with the intent to (try to) wear it as a tunic to liven up some of my none-too-frequent nights out and I'm pretty excited it looks ok with jeans and velvet. You know how things can go very differently in reality than fantasy, ha.
Amy, Carambola, Beth Ann, Suz -- Finally, thanks for *your* input on the mid-life crisis angle and kind words. I for sure won't wear it as a mini dress unless I can (fake?) project poise and mature confidence. And Beth Ann, you're reminding me that stuff I often think is "too young" for me would be deemed "way ooooold" by the women I think would wear it. Funny how that works.
ps Merwoman, daughters are the best/worst critics, right? I should have borrowed my young adult niece at the holiday, ha.