Exploring the Definition of Edgy Style

We recently had a lively forum discussion about the definition of edgy style. The different perspectives on the subject are well worth a read, but here it is in a nutshell: There is no one way to be edgy. 

I don’t believe that lots of black, leather, rugged boots, distressed fabrics, studs, zippers, tattoos, and creating a general “rough around the edges” look is the only way to look edgy. These outfit elements describe one type of edge — a “hard edge”. It’s probably the most popular way to create an edgy style because these items have been trending for years and are easily accessible. Ironically, hard edge has become a lot more mainstream than it used to be. 

To me edge is all about combining clothing, footwear and accessories in unconventional and unexpected ways. And in many cases, creating outfits with proportions that are not conventionally flattering.

Edge isn’t about a specific style persona. Whether your style is bohemian, modern classic, rock ’n’ roll, androgynous, arty eclectic, trendy fashionista, preppy classic, avant-garde, or sporty natural, you can create edge with unusual outfit juxtapositions. More specifically, edge is not incompatible with polish, pastels, lots of white and soft flowing fabrications. Here Tilda Swinton and Cate Blanchett’s style are good examples.

Edge can be about irregular or unusual pieces that have an edgy effect all on their own. But you can also create an edgy look by combining conventional pieces in unconventional ways, especially when the colours are interesting. This is part of a larger point that I like to shout from the rooftops: it’s HOW you wear an item that makes the difference, and not necessarily the style of the piece itself. 

Edginess is a continuum. You can add a little or a lot of edge to your style depending on which makes you feel best, or is most appropriate for your work environment and lifestyle. It is very common for people to dress with more edge in non-work settings, but sometimes the opposite is also true, particularly for people who work in very creative environments.

Edginess is also relative and subjective. What feels edgy to you might seem very conventional to others. Conversely, an outfit combination that you find tame and expected might be perceived as edgy in your environment. And you can change the edginess in your outfits over time as your own perceptions and goals evolve. 

Footwear, hairstyles and eyewear are powerful vehicles for edge. You can add a significant amount of edge to a fairly classic and conventional outfit just by sporting a more daring and dramatic hairstyle, and/or pair of specs. There is also something about the grounding integrity of footwear that ups the edge factor of an outfit when the style is particularly unique, or remixed in an interesting way. 

Finally, edginess is by no means a prerequisite for, or guarantee of, great style. Some of the greatest examples of personal style are to be found in beautiful, conventionally flattering looks. What is important is how you feel about your outfits. If irregular outfit juxtapositions seem too jarring, unflattering, or inappropriate for your professional or social environmental norm, then they might not be stylish for you. But if you’re comfortable challenging convention, then edginess can be stylish. If you are a little uncomfortable about an edgy combination, but excited by doing something different, then it might be just the tonic your personal style needs.

This is the beauty of style in 2014. There is no one way to be edgy, and no one way to be stylish. Express yourself, be daring if that’s what floats your boat, and above all, have fun with fashion.

Fab Finds: Booties & Boyfriend Jeans

Full length boyfriend jeans are hard to find, as are low heeled booties sans the Western cowboy vibe. Here are fab finds that fit the bill. 

  • Big Star Joey Slouchy Jeans: With a 34 inch inseam and tapered hem width, this length works for tall ladies with a little length to spare. You might need to size down if you prefer a less baggy and slouchy style. The hems and lower leg are wider so consider yourself warned if you prefer a streamlined fit. On the other hand, the fit is ideal for larger calves. 
  • True Religion Brianna Tumbleweed Boyfriend Jeans: This boyfriend jeans style is very streamlined. In fact, they look more like roomy straight legs than boyfriend jeans. They run true to size, but size up if you prefer a roomier fit. They are 100% cotton so no stretch and lots of authentic denim crunch. 
  • Cheap Monday Cube Heeled Ankle Boots: The refined-chunky appearance here is unique. A pointy toe with a cubed heel looks really fresh for Spring. The streamlined ankle fit is a plus and they are pretty comfortable after the addition of a cushioning insole. I found that the tops cut into my shins as I walked, which is why they didn’t work for me. But remember that I am Queen Fussy Feet, and will not compromise because I walk a lot and need to be comfortable. They might work for you. 
  • Jeffrey Campbell Oriley Ankle Boot: A forum member recommended these because they’re comfortable, edgy, and look great. The top flap folds down as an extra design feature, and you can tuck the front part of your skinnies into them for an interesting effect. A great cut-out style for Spring. 

Jeans worn with booties, in all sorts of combinations, has become one of the most popular casual bottoms combinations for my clients. It’s rivaling the oh-so-practical combination of jeggings tucked into tall boots.

Cheap Monday Cube Heeled Ankle BootsBig Star Joey Slouchy Fit Jean in 17 Year Dust

Affiliates
Some of the links in this post generate commissions for YLF.

The Pros and Cons of Ponchos

A poncho is an unstructured and loose outer garment that draws its inspiration from the authentic South American poncho. It’s usually made of a knit or a woven wool, and was originally designed to keep you warm. 

Ponchos were fashionable about ten years ago, but those looked different to the ones that are trending now. Those ponchos were often plaid, had fringe, sometimes a hood, and resembled some sort of blanket. Current ponchos tend to look more like knitwear or capes and are available in lots of variations. Neutrals or colours. Short or long sleeves. High or low necklines. Long or cropped lengths. Functional or faux sleeves. Fine gauge or chunky knits. Patterns or solids. Light or heavyweights. They usually showcase a high-low and/or asymmetrical hemline, and are oversized in the extreme, which creates excessive fabric drape.

My clients run the gamut when it comes to wearing ponchos because the look has its pros and cons.

Pros

  • Dramatic: The excessive drape, asymmetrical hemline and volume creates a theatrical effect. You’ll probably like the look if you have an arty eclectic or avant-garde streak to your style. 
  • Forgiving: It covers the body with loose, unstructured layers that do not cling. 
  • Easy: It’s a throw-on-and-go piece that creates an interesting effect with a simple pair of bottoms. 
  • Comfortable: Its unstructured design and soft fabrication makes for a cozy piece. 
  • Practical: It’s an excellent topper for mild Winter weather. Leave off the coat, and wear a poncho with slim fit jeans or trousers and boots. 

Cons

  • Unflattering: The sack-like silhouette and voluminous nature looks unflattering to those who prefer wearing structured pieces.
  • Uncomfortable: Ponchos can be drafty and “lots of fabric”, which can cause discomfort. Some prefer the comfort and warmth of closely fitting pieces. 
  • Too Bohemian: Too casual, frivolous and dramatic.
  • Impractical: It’s hard to layer a jacket or coat over a poncho, which makes it hard to wear outdoors unless the temperature is just right. 

Petites can wear ponchos when they aren’t too long or overly voluminous, so don’t think that you have to be tall to pull off the silhouette. Furthermore, a solid colour, tailored sleeves, or shorter sleeves do wonders to streamline the unstructured style on a smaller and/or shorter height. 

Although I love unstructured pieces, the drapey and swingy integrity of the poncho is too arty, whimsical, boho, and avant-garde for my personal style preferences. That said, I like the pink style below because it’s more streamlined on the hips. I like the look on others, and encourage my casually eclectic, artistic, and bohemian clients to give the poncho a go.

Over to you. What’s your take on the modern poncho?

Portolano Poncho with SleevesEileen Fisher Turtleneck Wool Poncho

27 Miles Lexie Striped Poncho

Vince Poncho Style SweaterFoxcroft Plaid Poncho Sweater

Ami Dans La Rue Solid Poncho Sweater2nd Day Knitted Poncho in Twisted Yarn

TOMAS MAIER Cashmere PonchoDONNA KARAN Modal Jersey PonchoDONNA KARAN Draped Cashmere Poncho

Roundups

Simpler Items

This week's list of top picks list is about basic pieces.

Read More

Assorted Items

Items for Summer, both in and out of air conditioning.

Read More

Casual Summer Vibes

This week's top picks are good for a casual Summer vibe.

Read More

Summery Earth Tones

These items are for those who like to wear casual earth tones in warm and hot weather.

Read More

Hints of Spring

Some tried-and-tested winning items to refresh your style for Spring.

Read More

Dressier Items

An assortment of dressier top picks might be just what the doctor ordered.

Read More

Ensemble: Winter Whiteout

“Whiteout” means wearing shades of white from head to toe, or almost head to toe. The idea is that white comes in many shades, and that you wear some of them together in one outfit. Shades of white include bright optical white, a softer off-white, warm rich cream, a cool grey bone or stone (like an extremely light grey), or very light tan. 

First, a few tips about putting the look together:

  • I’ve found that keeping the whites of two of the items in an outfit a close colour match creates outfit cohesion, and goes a long way to making the look feel pulled together. I like to match the white of my boots with the white of my jeans, belt or bag. Or I wear the same colour cream both on the top and bottom, while wearing a different shade of white footwear and topper. 
  • Don’t feel the need to wear white, bone, tan or cream footwear with the outfit. By all means bookend the colour of your hair with black, grey, taupe, cognac or brown footwear. Or sport metallic footwear. 
  • Whiteout can be interpreted in both casual and dressy ways. The casual ensemble on the left is with jeans, while the dressier version on the right is with crepe trousers. 

This is not meant to be a practical look. But it’s awfully pretty, and a refreshing way to wear light neutrals. It’s like wearing brights without the colour. 

White Out

Here are the components of the ensemble:

White Bottoms: Wear white, cream or stone jeans or trousers. By all means wear a skirt if that’s more to your liking. 

White Tops: Layer two tops in different shades of white, or stick to one white top. Wear a white button-down shirt or soft blouse under a pullover, or wear either the blouse or the pullover. I’ve chosen pullovers here because warm knitwear is trending, but feel free to choose cardigans or fine gauge knitwear instead. I’ve found that white knitwear looks best fluid or oversized because it adds depth to the colour. If you tuck, faux tuck or semi-tuck your top, then add a white or light snakeskin belt. 

Footwear: Finish off the outfit with footwear in a shade of white, or in a neutral that bookends the colour of your hair, or in a metallic. Patterned footwear like light-coloured snake skin is another option, or even cheetah and leopard. Choose tall boots, mid-calf boots, booties, pumps, oxfords or loafers. Wear nude hose for warmth when socks are not an option. 

Topper: Add a blazer, leather jacket, wool coat or trench coat in a shade of white. If you don’t have a topper in a shade of white, go with black, grey, taupe, brown or ink blue. Or throw on a topper in blush pink or other very soft shade of pastel. Leave off the topper in mild Winter weather. 

Accessories: A bag in a shade of white is a gorgeous complement, as is a shade of silver, pewter or gold. Repeating the colour of non-white footwear also works, like wearing a cognac bag with cognac booties. Or black bag with black booties. Add a scarf in the same tonal white palette if you’re after extra outfit texture and detail. Finish off with jewellery and eyewear as desired. 

Check out my White on White pinboard for extra inspiration.  

This ensemble pulls at my heartstrings because I love all shades of white. To my eye, wearing them together makes a luxurious, crisp statement. I’ve been wearing the formula even more regularly this Autumn and Winter and enjoying it tremendously. I feel somewhat angelic and rebellious at the same time. Rebellious, because I’m normally the only person on rainy Seattle streets wearing all white at this time of year. Personally I don’t find it all that impractical, but I am extra careful on the days I wear it.

Link Love: Leather Looks

I’m still loving all my trousers, but am also in the mood to wear skirts again more often in 2014. That’s why I enjoyed browsing these leather skirt looks, I’m especially drawn to the full midis.
 
If you like to change things up and are looking for an alternative to smooth leather, then have a look at this crinkled leather Refinery29 roundup.
 
This Huffington Post article confirms that vegan leather continues to gain popularity. The improved quality, affordability and the movement towards socially conscious shopping all play a role in this.

Fab Links from Our Members

Dianthus enjoys browsing framework, an online magazine with interesting articles on both fashion and decorating.

At the start of the new year Bridgette Raes’ post on considering fashion and style as it relates to your goals really resonated with Aquamarine.

Pil found this excerpt from a Wall Street Journal article about online retailers and the cost of returns very interesting.

Angie thought it was fun to flashback to 2003 trends and compare them to what happened ten years later. 

For the thrifters among us, Joy wants to share this NYT article about the prevalence of high-low style in 2013.

Vildy likes to think about the meaning behind clothing and the Clothes on Film website contains lots of links to articles about and interviews with costume designers.

Adelfa found this article about why women have so many clothes and how it’s so easy to get it wrong a fascinating read.