I love this outfit - both versions! I can't decide which shoe I like better, I think they both look fantastic.

I like the lighter coloured shoe. These window panes make every outfit look awesome.

Gah! Tormented by the pants that got away. Love those ^^ I like both shoes. Perhaps the issue with the lighter pair is that your legs are shortened further than with the black pair. You just gotta roll with it

Your legs look super long to me and I love the long cobalt jacket. Don't make me pick a shoe though - you can't lose either way!

You look great, i prefer the black!

I like both looks, though to me the black shoe outfit is more cohesive and restful somehow, not necessarily what you are going for! I have versions of all of these pieces--I'll have to try!

Oh wow, perfection. I would pick the black shoes but for YOU I would pick the first pair!