Thanks Amy, Shevia and Jackie! I guess something can look good and not feel right at the same time. I'm longing for some well fitting neutral stuff...

Oh, wow, I would so keep those jeans. They don't look too out there at all, they just add some interest, especially worn with the other dark neutrals. If somehow that's not what your crowd wears and you feel uncomfortable, I could see that, but just as an outfit I think it's perfect.