I keep a spreadsheet too, and of the 88 items on it, 18 were purchased in 2015 or earlier. These are the only ones I have Finds for
burgundy faux-leather jacket (2014) - I bought this for a writer's conference I attended that year and have been wearing it dressed up and down ever since. I've tried to find a real leather replacement and failed repeatedly, which is a shame because the faux leather is now cracking and peeling. I should let it go, but I haven't been able to convince myself yet.
Fossil tote (2014) - a perennial essential
Ariat western boots (2011) - bought for a Western-themed party to celebrate our return to Colorado, but I always intended to wear them forever, and I have
Born lace-up boots (2006) - these aren't as comfortable as they once were, but I still pull them out a few times a year. So great with dresses.
Duluth Trading flannel (pre-2011) - bought while we still lived in Seattle - it's amazing that this barely shows any signs of wear after more than ten years
Other standouts without Finds include my Eddie Bauer down jacket and vest, two beloved graphic tees, a scarf that was given to my mother while she was in high school, a black clutch from Target that never seems to become dated, and a crochet bag made for me by my sister-in-law.