Well I expected just as much from a group of fashionistas!
In thinking more about this, I realized that with items I love, the details matter (i.e. lace up boots vs. zipper boots, heel height, shaft height, leather sheen, stitching) and thus justify buying many versions. With items I hate shopping for, they are all the same to me (pumps, bras, t shirts, button downs)... Boring and difficult to fit or find.
In my heart I know that is not the case, but it's how I feel. If I had any sense I'd pay more attention to the details of the things I hate as that is probably what is causing the issue in the first place.