Firecracker (Sharan) - The Caslon terry shirts are a home run for me this NAS. Both blue colors (navy and skyway blue) work well with my wardrobe. I'll report back on the Wit & Wisdom when they arrive. I have one pair of Wit & Wisdom that are white jeans which have been nice. Most of my jeans are Paige. Mother is a new brand for me. So far, comparing Paige to Mother, I find the Paige denim is slightly thicker but not overly so.
delurked - It is sometimes difficult to find a top in the right length. Often shirts are way too long for me (same with layering tanks and tees). But these Caslon terry shirts are a home run this NAS, the length is perfect for me.
Suz - The Caslon terry shirts are definitely a top find for me this NAS. They are perfect. I'll report back on the Wit & Wisdom when they arrive. I am very curious which brand will work better.
Angie - If I was writing a top picks list, the Caslon terry shirts would be at the top of it. Both blue shades have been a home run for me this NAS. And indeed, the fabric is super cozy. I can't wait for the weather to cool enough to start wearing them.
I'll post the comparison when the Wit & Wisdom arrive. The Mother's seem really nice. The material is slightly thinner than my Paige, but not enough to be a deal breaker. The lighter weight denim may be useful with our long hot season.
kkards - *high five for jeans* I adore a good pair of jeans that fit well, are comfortable, and a wash that's versatile. Jeans are my favorite bottom to wear, year after year. I never tire of jeans.
RobinF - I appreciate that these jeans do not need to be hemmed. Even when I do an original hem on a pair of jeans with a finished hem, it's just not the same when the jeans have been tailored for length adjustments.
unfrumped - Your plans for the Caslon shirt is the same as mine, it's going to be a great layering piece for our warm falls when we have cool mornings and hot afternoons. I hope the navy works for you! It's a great shirt.
Julie - Thanks for the feedback on the Wit & Wisdom. It will be interesting to compare them to the Mother's. I'm 5'3" so there's a good chance they will fit me full length.
Angie - I actually went down a size in the Mother's. The Mother's are a size 27. Paige jeans I already own are a size 28. My Wit & Wisdom white jeans are a size 4.
gryffin - I have not tried COH but in Paige I also size up in skinnies and straight legs. The Cindy is my favorite fit in Paige denim.