Angie - I knew you’d say that about the EF’s , as Janet’s style is most definitely NOT EF influenced . And I appreciate how you have differentiated between dated-for-one is not dated-for-another . I tend to be uberconscious of that for my own shoe buying and rarely let a pair hang around for longer than 2 -3 seasons tops . But we all have different ideas as to what trends we want to adopt or not .

I'm glad that made sense, Lisa p. People like you, Tanya, Denise, UmmLila, Anna, Staysfit and Janet are very trendy with your shoes. You revaluate strongly every season and want the trendiest. Find it harder to wear last season's shoes again. The trendy shoes are part of your signature look. They are NOT for my style. Like I said in my comment before yours - "I tend to stick to more classic styles and wear them into the ground. I am trendier in my clothing than in my footwear choices. My shoes seldom date. They just wear out!"

This is how I updated my shoes for Spring & Summer. Apart from the mules - not very trendy. But dead right for my feet and style. Horses for courses - always

Well stated Angie! Although I definitely purchase trendy shoes every year, the bulk of my shoe collection is made up of fairly classic shoes like ballet flats, loafers, and pumps that I wear for years, don’t seem to go out of style, and last a long time. I’m not sure they are statements. I definitely purchase trendy shoes every season, often at a lower price, that I don’t expect to wear for more than one or two years. They may or may not be statements.

Janet I love your shoe collection. I am not going to dissect it because I can't beat the advice upthread. I do find the idea of dated for you interesting and helpful. I am going to look at my own shoes in that light.

Such a great post and thread. You’ve a great selection of shoes. I love your top 6, 1 especially. Interesting reading and great to look at the selection.

Janet Angie seems to be saying your slip on sneakers are just too “pedestrian”- get it? Teehee

I love your in-depth analysis and pictures of your shoe wardrobe. Wish I had time to come in on everything but just to say I love your style these shoes are amazing

Why do you have to give any away? (Hehe)

Janet you have an amazing shoe collection! I would love to have a store nearby offering all your options. I would want many. You have received excellent advice from others. My only recurring thought is that if any of your shoes are troublesome (escaping toes, short straps, wrong color, a little beat up) is to let them go. Do they really still make you happy? You have plenty of others to choose from. You won’t go barefoot.

Janet, it is so interesting to see your analysis and how accurate that has been. Angie has probably confirmed what you were already thinking in relation to what you wanted to update.

The great thing is you can be picky, because your current collection is so comprehensive and works perfectly for your style.

Huge thanks, everyone! This is helpful. Heck, just the process of putting on each pair and snapping a photo was helpful. I'm ready to pass along a few pairs now.

Interestingly, Angie, I'm not ready to give away the EF sandals yet. I got those last year and find them really useful for very casual days with lots of walking -- they're sturdy and really casual but substantial (and not slip-ons), and a really versatile color, and sometimes that's just what I need. I'm not sure what an updated version of that would look like, but I'll be keeping an eye out.

In fact, that's my trouble with this whole sandal thing -- I'm not totally sure what updated versions of some old favorites should be! I'm kinda over those old Cole Haan thong-style sandals (but big props to CH for really well-made sandals that have lasted through 5 years!). But I don't see anything out there that makes me go "ooh! that's it!" Maybe it's not a good season for sandals because everything seems to be about mules.

Speaking of which, Angie, no, no mules for me yet. I find them cute when I see them in photos but I'm unsure about them on me, with my summer wardrobe, and with my flattery priorities? (I'm a little unsure about how they look on less-than-fab legs) I've tried on a couple of pairs but quickly determined they did not work for me -- either not comfortable, bad fit, or they looked odd. I guess I'm just not used to them -- I have memories of walking out of them, and sweaty feet. I suppose I need to try some on.

Oh, and for sure, I'm ready to let some go because I DO have plenty of options in my closet. I'd be happy having a little less choice but better selections to choose from. If I can find two versatile, amazing replacements for 6-8 pairs, I'll be happy. Preferably flat or very low heels good for lots of casual walking. And neutral -- maybe a pair in black, and a pair in silver/metallic.

With that in mind, perhaps I need to ease up on my determination to find budget options. Two really fab pairs of sandals at $300 each might serve me better than six pairs of $100 sandals. I learned from those LD Turtles that pricey sandals can be worthwhile! Those are not exactly trendy, but they're so distinctive (and well made) that they have worked for me for years.

Janet, that was a HECTIC photo taking an uploading process. It yielded excellent conversation though - so thank you.

May I suggest a holding zone for anything that you are unsure about. Feel your way with your new sandal purchases. You have classics that need replacing - easy. Get new slides. And have fun trying on mules.

I'm glad it was helpful for others and not just me! I really appreciate all the feedback.

I have an errand to run at the mall today (and my car needs a bath, and there's a good detailer who works there right outside of Nordstrom!), so maybe I'll look at mules while I'm there.

I like the following: 1,2,7,10,15, 22, 33, 42. I'm not a fan of thong sandals because they are usually too flat to walk around in and those thong parts hurt my feet :). It seems like these are keepers for you too.

Hi Janet --

What a collection, and they look lovely on you!

I'm a boring shoe person myself but have the higher-heeled espadrille style of the Eileen Fisher in 2 colors, one a DIY metallic (note: style poorly made, I've had to reglue the straps into the sole, hopefully they've fixed the issue several seasons on). I agree they're ridiculously great for walking as the straps are butter-soft.

For your style I'd think treating them like a sneaker alternative might keep you on the proverbial right path.

Which reminds me -- you certainly don't need a reason to keep any, but if it's just the color that is off I'd for sure slap some Tarrago shoe cream in metallic or pearly on and see if that improves things. If interested choose the darkest silvers for better coverage/transformation. [must be the shoe cream, not other types...shoeshinekit.com is a vendor I rec]. You can easily layer colors and/or create a RATE look.