Chris987 - I agree with the thrift store assessment. I can never figure out how and where anyone finds the good stuff.
Brooklyn - my favourite sweater of the past year or so is cotton, and I didn't even realize it until I looked at the label recently to figure out what it was made of so I could replicate it. Ha. It's a very densely woven fine gauge brushed cotton with a bit of a drape, and totally warm enough for winter here.
Thank you all, for the outfit approval. You know when something just clicks while you are putting it together ? Best feeling ever I wore that sweater all day for work, and it showed not one hint of stretching out, wasn't at all itchy, and no sign of pilling starting. Best $35 I've spent in ages !
As to the ebay order - the seller has 5 star reviews and bills her/himself as a closet cleaning reseller of designer goods. The scarf I ordered is apparently new with tags. Keeping my fingers crossed.