Saddlebags, my bucket bag! You are gorgeous.
However, I know exactly how you feel because we are body doubles. Or nearly so. I always feel like I have saddle bags, too. It's just the the width of our hips is a bit lower, probably due to a slightly long rise vs. a shorter waist.
Anyway, here is the thing. Your legs may be (slightly) shorter relative to your torso, but we are talking slight. The camera angle here exaggerates any shortness of leg (foreshortens you). Meanwhile, you are not wearing shoes!! Footwear will make an enormous difference to the way that all of these look, adding at least an inch to your leg length and likely 2 or more. This is why they always suggest trying dresses with the footwear you intend to use.
You look great in a sheath, an A-line, a swing dress, and a shift. I love how you have tried all the styles!
My absolute favourites on you here are #2 (gorgeous!), 7, 8, 10, and 14. #3 has potential but does not fit in the torso length -- that style of skirt could work though, in a different item.
The problem with #1 is not that it is a sheath. Or even that the skirt is too long. Yes, in these photos you do look better with dresses at a slightly shorter length, but footwear could change that.
The problem is that the skirt does not taper at the bottom and feels too stiff/ heavy/ overwhelming. I have this exact issue with pencil skirts that don't narrow. Straight skirts, I guess they are called. I look about 100 times better in one that tapers a bit or a lot. A straight midi skirt looks frumpalicious on me, whereas a tapered midi tube skirt is suddenly downright flattering with a slight heel and JFE even with sneakers!! The taper adds just enough structure to prevent the length from overwhelming me.
It is similar with jeans. While a calf-sucking skinny isn't great on me, a slim BF cut that narrows towards the ankle is more flattering than a regular straight cut on my shape. This is why I love the R&B Dres.
