There's nothing like a couple of days of trying on shoes to put me in my place and remind me how very limited my options are if I am to prioritize comfort in my footwear.
I've eliminated many of the boots from my original list. Haven't even bothered to try on the Docs because they don't have side zippers.
Hoped to try on the Ecco Nouvelle boots today but the local store didn't have them in, so I'll either have to order them or wait until they're in stock.
I also tried on a pair of chestnut brown Remonte booties this afternoon (first find. also comes in black -- second find). The slightly lower shaft actually seemed to be a bit more flattering on my leg than the shaft of the Blundstones. These aren't quite as comfortable though -- they would likely be okay as an office shoe or for shorter outings rather than all day jaunts. Price is almost half of what the Blundstones will set me back...
And there's the rub -- I used to legitimately need a variety of footwear that was basically for the office only. Now that I'm only in the office a couple of days a week (and who knows for how much longer) how many such shoes can I justify?
I already have three pairs of shoes that are pretty much "office only" -- cream oxfords, burgundy oxfords and a black patent loafer. I also have white, bronze and toffee sneakers.
I'm still tempted to bring the Remontes home for a bit more evaluation, but I am coming to realize that the most pressing need is for a comfortable, casual boot.
Despite my lack of success with other brands, I know Blundstones are a viable option, and I could opt for one of several colours -- Oat, camel (haven't seen it IRL yet), antique brown, or burgundy could all probably prove useful in my casual life with some possible crossover the the office. But which?
Oat? Maybe. I have a lightweight cream puffer, and lots of scarves with cream in the pattern. Would work with most colours. I'd probably need to buy a cream purse.
Burgundy? Maybe. I have a light burgundy puffer and several fall weight scarves with burgundy in them.
Antique brown or camel? I currently carry a cognac brown crossbody bag that would coordinate with either of these brown tones. I have lots of fall scarves with brown in them. Would work better than burgundy with my green sweaters. I could also opt for the cognac colour in the dress boot style, so really three brown options.
Decisions, decisions.... I'll think about it tomorrow....