Need urgent advice: which color shoes?

I decided to pounce and order the slipper flats from this post before my hard to find size is gone!
I will order both silver and gold Isaac Mizhari flats because I need to see colors in person to decide and both colors have a potential for me.
However for Me Too flats I cannot make up my mind which color to get. Yellow are gone in my size but black, grey and rosewood are available.
Pic 4 - 6 are my current summer shoes. I have nude Fidji pumps and nude cage wedge sandals. I don't know if Rosewood color is close to the nude one because I have a suspicion that I should not add another pair of nude shoes. On the other hand they are of a different style so maybe it makes sense...
I don't have any black summer footwear now. Should I get a black pair or black shoes is not a good option for the summer? On the other hand this perforation makes black 'less black" IYKWIM...
As for the grey - I like the idea of the grey footwear but not sure if this particular color is going to work with my skin and my wardrobe. I have grey low wedge pumps and grey oxfords but they are spring and fall shoes, not high summer as I hope these flats will be.
For the reference this what I have in summer bottoms:
- black / white patterned skirts;
- white bermudas;
- dark blue denim clams and BF;
- light wash BF;
- micro check cropped pants - black and white but looks like grey
- blush pink trousers

What would be your color pick for me? I really appreciate the collective YLF wisdom here as my mind does not want to solve this problem!
ETA: I forgot to add that I will be ordering them to be delivered to the border and have to drive to pick them up so I would like to eliminate options which are not good before I order if possible.

This post has 6 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

11 years ago

Anonymous

I would pick the grey ones!

Jaime

(website)

Veteran

I would order the ones that might work and then return the ones that don't. Hard to judge how they will work with your skin tone from website pictures.

Caro in Oz

I would pick grey:)

Transcona Shannon

Good idea to jump while you can Sveta!

I really like the grey colour of the Me Too flats. Although I love the rosewood colour too, I think it is too similar in colour to your other summer shoes and it would be nice to have something different. As you know, grey can be a tricky colour and unfortunately you won't know if it is the right grey until you see it in person.

I'm not opposed to black - I agree that the perforations do make it less heavy looking.

I guess it all boils down to what works best overall with your summer wardrobe.

Thistle

Do you get free return? If so, what Aida said. If not, I like the rosewood ones best.

Glory

another vote for the grey ones.

hedgiehog

Grey, rosewood...preferred in that order. What goes with most of what you have? Are you keeping the other summer shoes? If yes, then definitely grey.

Angie

Fashion Stylist

Grey!

Joy

Sveta, the grey are not really a grey but almost more of a denim color. The rosewood are sort of a dark nude, but probably not different enough in color from what you have. They will go with your blush trousers I think. Actually the photo colors are pretty true. Black may work well for you since your hair is dark. Personally I'd rather show more foot I. A summer black shoe.
This was probably not very helpful.

CocoLion

You can't go wrong with any of the three, but based on what you have, I see a need for black or nude the most. Grey is somewhere in between and can work where a nude works, sometimes, but it really depends on the shade of grey.

Suz

I would say grey, but I can also see an argument for black, as it would bookend your dark hair. And in some summer outfits that might be useful.

sarah

Grey. The rosewood repeats your other neutrals, and black is such a pain to bookend.

Karie

I would go for the grey!

Sveta

So far grey is a winner - this was my first pick too!
I think I will order both grey and black - just in case this grey color does not work for me.

Thank you all for your help - you are the best bunch in the world!!!!!!

Just placed an order - fingers crossed SOMETHING will work!

Category