Well this has been very interesting to read ladies - definitely a variety of responses here! Now it's time for me to reveal more info about these three choices...
#1/2 - my first choice. The colour doesn't quite translate in the photos very well but it's such a rich red/brown and I love the touch of black/white gingham on the arm. I do have a bit of concern that they are slightly too big for my face though. That can work to my advantage however since I wear progressive bi-focals and will give me a larger reading portion than I currently have.
#3/4 - the SA's first choice. They fit me extremely well (face width and bridge) and the turqoise arms (again, doesn't show up in the pics) are gorgeous. Kristin came with me and she liked these ones the best as well.
#5 - just a random pair of red because I always thought I'd like a red pair of glasses. Although these are nicest colour of the reds I tried on, I think I would tire of them quickly.
Cinnamon Fern - thanks for the pics of the Warby Parker specs. Unfortunately those would be huge on my face (not in width, but vertical height).
Will probably look at a few more styles yet - hope you don't mind!