I agree with Bijou that this is such a personal decision and there is nothing wrong with a decision to dye or not to dye.
That said, it’s obvious that I (reluctantly) took the pandemic as the opportunity to grow out my natural undyed color. I had no plans to grow my hair out, but before I knew it I had six months of growth and felt like I didn’t want to go through that all over again someday when I had even more grey!
Do I love my grey hair? Not really. But I’m accepting it, and I like it more than I did a year ago. I get compliments on it, which surprises me, but I accept them with gratitude. I’m aware that it does very likely make me look “older” but I’m trying not to cling to preconceived notions of what is aging and what aging should or shouldn’t look like. I’m 56 and am not ever going to be mistaken for 40 again.
On a solemn note, I will offer one bit of info that my BFF gave me, which helped nudge me away from coloring my hair. She is a surgeon currently specializing in breast cancer surgery. There is recent data linking certain permanent hair dye and straightener chemicals to breast cancer rates. Having lost another BFF to breast cancer, that news was sobering.
I think that transitioning to grey hair does take some time emotionally as well as physically. It’s an adjustment to see yourself with a different color, but I think it’s also much more jarring if you’ve always had dark hair. I think blondes have an easier time of it because the contrast level stays the same. However, I know the shift from warm to cool tones is a whole other adjustment!
For me, it’s important to find a modern, intentional style for my newly grey hair. The greys have a different texture from my colored hair and can look dull and frizzy, so extra care is necessary too.
I do think you look great with the growout, and you have a terrific youthful energy, no matter what color your hair! I’ll be curious to see what you choose.