Tanya - good to know Matisse makes a comfy shoe. My feet aren't too fussy but as I get older I find shoes that aren't super comfy get a pass.
Kkards - oh how I wish I could order from Zappos! I used them for the find but I'm in Canada so I'd probably order from shoeme which seems to work well for some on the forum. Haven't tried shoeme before - I really don't like to buy footwear online but sometimes there's just no choice.
Janet - how I'd love to find a pair that adjusts on the first strap AND zips up the back. I haven't been able to find such an animal. I could see my lazy birk-wearing self getting frustrated by tying every time! Those finds are great and you have great taste in footwear - I just don't do heels much!
Suz - for daily wear I only do flat footwear. How I love it when I can find flat footwear that looks good and adds a style element when the rest of the outfit is ho-hum because it's so hot and humid. We were lucky last summer with temps but I can't imagine that kind of summer is here to stay. Not sure what this year will bring but I've been trying for the past couple of summers to not look like I totally gave up for 2-3 months!
Vix - suede is more forgiving! I hadn't even thought of that - good point. Sandals are a strange animal in the fit department. In closed shoes /boots I usually do 6.5 (which is probably cheating to accommodate my wide foot). That strategy just doesn't fly with sandals. And, of course, when I go down a size it just gets narrower, add swelling feet and it's no wonder why I love my birks!