Great looks! I agree with all that #2 is a go! It is just lovely on you. I think the splashes of lightness really complement your tones. I really like #3. I must say I have only a couple of dresses in that style (I like the style of #2 for myself as well!) but I do feel they are lovely for a change. I can imagine how well it moves, too. I don't think you will regret it. #1 is a bit short for work, in my opinion. But I can really imagine it is as weekend workhorse.

I love #1. Love it. Not sure if I would wear it to work. I worked it a similar work environment as you. It might work with capri leggings if you wanted to wear it to work. I prefer it with flats. Just me.
I also like the other 2 dresses. I agree that movement makes a big difference. Video clips would be amazing.

Rachylou, please read the very first comment. You are not the only one

i like all of them, each for a different occasion, i think they all fit well

Love # 1 for a versatile casual piece just the way it is. The perfect denim dress to my eye. #2 is unquestionably a keeper, totally flattering. #3 is the one I'm not as sure of, but as you say, it is difficult to get the whole picture from a still photo. Imo your body suits a shift style over a fuller skirt.

It all depends on your needs, but to my eyes, nr 2 is perefct, pls. KEEP!!! Can be dressed up and down and it is a great fit and length, with flattering colors and trendy floral!
Next is nr 3. looks like an easy but still very great dress but the neckline is a bit high. You can dress this when so inclined-also great for not showing that much of a cleavage when bending:-).
Nr 1 is very casual (the tie gives me pause a bit) and short- but you have great legs, and will be so very great with some flats or lower wedges!

Basically ditto to everything Lyn just said above.

Hi SF --

My impressions --

#2 is a no-brainer. The colors read as "True Summer" to me but a) the overall impression is very light thanks to the white parts (which echo the tones in your hair) and b) I actually think you look great in that level of contrast.

#1 I like (minority!) but the rope belt does take it into juniors territory for me seems at odds with your usual casual preferences. Maybe a highly textured belt in one of your key neutrals or fav color-colors? Agree it'd be fun to wear as a tunic, too.

#3 looks a little prim, as fuller-skirted midis often do these days when they don't show upper chest (and I say that as someone who loves the swish of a full midi!). I can see why you were drawn to it.

For daytime I might try to add some light but dangly earrings or something that's a bit fun. I might also try a very narrow belt to make that area between bodice and skirt look a bit more "grown up" and set off your slender waist.

Another fan on #2 for you. Not too dark at all ! I agree with the suggestions to lose the belt with the first dress and wear it with flats. It does look a little short to me but those changes would make it great for a weekend dress. Not a fan of the third one - but it's completely out of my style zone so nothing helpful from me on that one.

Chiming in late to say I *adore* #2 on you. The cut is spot-on and colors are great for summer. Definite keeper.

#1 I have mixed feelings about. It looks like there's extra bulk in the torso? And I'm not a fan of the rope belt -- is it possible to swap it out for a different belt or sash?

#3 I *think* is a keeper, but I so desperately want to see it styled... a scarf, a topper, a big bold pendant...? It definitely needs something to make it come alive. I think those who mentioned it being a little on the dark side might be right. Maybe pair with lighter shoes and a white or ivory denim jacket!

I have to chime in and say #2 and they are out of the gate.

I really like #2. You look amazing in it.

Maybe dress #3 is just one that doesn't photograph well as you need to see the movement of the fabric?

Hmm, I truly appreciate all the feedback. The belt on dress #1 does not come out easily, it goes through grommets rather than traditional belt loops. I may return it and keep looking for something similar but longer. I like the pocket details and the sleeve length.

I'm questioning dress #3 also. I really don't NEED anything urgently so I can afford to wait for wardrobe items that look stellar. There are many comments about the neckline being unflattering, the skirt too full (my interpretation) and the proportions awkward. I think a dress should look good without the accessories. If I have to add accessories or cover up to make it work, isn't that a sign that something is wrong?

So, it looks like dress # 2 should stay.

Hahaha, Mauvish! It's a stunner, right? Lol.

Another fabber loving #2 -- so fresh and flattering! I like the other two, as well, and here's what is more important --- you seem to enjoy them, particularly #3. You're ready to defend it against slander, hee! I know part of it is because of the element we can't see -- movement. But I also think the dress must make you feel special -- and that's translates into the room, too. I think we behave differently and move differently when we're in a dress that floats about. It's lovely, and I say that even wishing the neckline were a bit more open, and the skirt a tad less fabric. Happiness factor gets the deciding vote!

I like 1 and 2 the best . Both are really nice on you. 3 is also good though, I love that sort of top too!