Lighting can be tricky so it's hard for me to say for sure which one works better with your complexion. I do know as we age sometimes certain paler colors can make us look more washed out while slightly brighter versions of the same color can really made our skin look glowy.
Here's a trick I learned a long time ago to determine which colors work best on me. You generally want to determine whether more of the undertones of your skin are cool or warm.
So fair skinned folk with cooler undertones often carry off cooler pale pinks much better than ones with warmer undertones, whereas the warmer undertoned skin-types usually look optimal in more warm pinks (coral, peach. etc.)
Look at the inside of your wrist and the underlying veins that you should be able to see there. Do the veins under your skin there look a bit more green or more blue?
If green (like mine) the undertones of your complexion are warm. So coral, peach, etc. will generally "do better things" for your complexion.
If the veins are bluer, then your complexion's natural undertones are more cool and cool pinks, violets, etc, generally will best compliment your skin tone.
This doesn't mean you can't wear the cooler shades if you're warm or vice/versa (because, hey, if you feel good in it and like it then I say wear it!) but if you're looking for a way to determine which color best accents and optimizes your complexion overall this is a handy trick.
I know I have a "peaches and cream" complexion. So my best shades are warmer (but I still do a lot of cooler shades as well, I'm just careful about putting certain shades up near my face, like shades of clothing that are ivory with gray/green undertones (instead of a warmer ivory) have a tendency to make me look sickly and zombie-like).
Hope this little trick helps some!