Sorry ladies, didn't mean to post and run! Truth is, I posted then fell asleep.
Thanks Windchime, Momo, Dee, Una, lyn
Pil and Suz, the top in 11 will semi-tuck (it's the same as the one in 3) but I'm not sure if it will with these pants. I must have tried that... I do prefer to semi-tuck this top because it's quite boxy.
Pil, sorry they Holts didn't work for you - I wasn't sure if the Holts would work for me... I ended up a half size bigger than my bigger size, to get the length. They seemed short in the heel area. Luckily they aren't too wide as a result!
Carter, you make me laugh. I'm honored that you actually pursue things that I like! That Zara sweater was pretty cheap to start with, and it's a great piece... definitely worth a mall trip. And the fabric of the BR sweater is glorious... I have a black one in my shopping cart as well :). Word of warning though - I did find it picked easily. I had 2-3 by the end of the day - got them all worked back in, no thread broke, but it's not as "tough" as it could be.
Joy, you should try the skirted leggings, I can definitely see you in them. They are a bit longer than I thought, which is a good thing... there is a place on my legs that shorts and skirts HAVE to come to. These do. They are so unbelievable comfortable. They have brought some longer tops and tunics into a different type of circulation in my wardrobe, which is what I hoped. I'm looking forward to styling them in the cooler weather - mine came in the spring so while the weather may not have warmed, I was done with heavier sweaters etc. You should also look at that BR sweater - it's a perfect pair for the pants - colour and style.
Sterling, thanks, and thanks again for your help with the EF linen top. I'm so glad I got them. I am 5'6". I'm curious as to how the Madewell top fits you differently? I actually would get this in a smaller size if I were to do it again - erred on the side of caution because some of the reviews said it may shrink a bit. But it really is big on me.