Hi Abie --
Super-pale and cool-toned checking in. Every summer I am on a quest to find what you're looking for (and I have lots of "musts" in addition to color so it's a huge PITA).
Do you wear (toe)nail polish, and if so, do you have any favorite light shades? That can be a good jumping-off point. Also handy to drag along if you are looking IRL.
For me whites, even soft whites, look terrible on my feet. In standard leather, I find bone or driftwood is my best pale shade.
Metallics are my preference since my shoes tend to not have much going for them, ha. Pale (#1-2) or medium (#6) rose-beige is my best nude/skintone match. Lavender patent (#3-4), silver, pewter (#5) and a very pink-coral (#8) are pretty good too. A few summers ago I started using metallic shoe leather creams to turn "not quite right" pale shades into better fits for me...#7 is one such result.
Unfortunately all sorts of weird undertones seem to come out when a shoe is on your foot, so to some degree it's trial and error; good luck!
This post has 8 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.
If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.