Kristen, I hope this story makes you feel better about shopping hazards:
Recently, I shared on "Where to Shop" that SmartBargains.com was having a one-day amazing sale on all premium denim. I rushed over and ordered two different pairs of white jeans and two in a dark wash. I got two sizes of each, figuring that one of each would fit me and the others would go back.
If you've ever bought premium denim (it's fairly new to me), you know that it's usually not sized like 0, 2, 4, 6 etc. but by waist size, so that sizes begin around a 23 or 24 and go up from there. I ordered two pairs from Rich & Skinny, 23 and 24, and two from Paige Premium, also 23 and 24.
Or so I thought. Imagine my surprise to open the package, pull out the jeans, and find that the Paige jeans follow regular sizing, and that I had carelessly neglected to note the little "W" in the size labeling. What I had ordered was a 24W.
I put them on to show my son the mistake I had made, and he hasn't stopped laughing. Now, let me say immediately that I do not find anything inherently humorous about plus-sized clothing or people of size. What was funny was how very wrong the jeans were on me. Just as silly-looking as me trying to wedge myself into a toddler-sized dress, or clomping around in my brother's size 13.5 shoes. The disproportion was funny, not the jeans themselves.
I briefly thought of posting a photo, but was concerned that it might be misunderstood and I would never risk hurting anyone's feelings in an attempt at humor. You'll have to picture it in your mind.
So Kristen, the navy/black issue is a totally understandable mistake. If you bought in a real store, the lighting was probably atrocious, and if you ordered it online, the website probably called the shade my pet-peeve, misleading, is-it-black-or-dark-blue color name: "Midnight."