So, I'm terribly late here. But first, let me say, that is awful about the stylist and no wonder you are distressed! Whew. What a pain, too, to have to look elsewhere. (I get it. I'm searching for a new stylist too, not because I don't adore mine, but because I can't travel to Vancouver and that's where she is.)
Now, as to the cut itself, it's aggravating in the extreme that you did not get what you wanted, but you look gorgeous to me, and I actually think it makes a really great change, showing you in a different light. I disagree that it "lacks edge" -- it takes a certain amount of courage to go super short, for one thing, especially in some communities -- and your eyes, cheekbones and skin really stand out. Having said that, I also agree that a switch up in cuts and require a switchup in clothing and makeup. Different necklines, jewellery, and even colours sometimes seem better. Luckily, you have a full closet! So you can experiment to find what will work best as this grows out into something you like better. I absolutely love Carla's inspo pictures -- she's amazing at collecting those -- but truly you look spectacular to me as you are right now. Admittedly, as a pixie lover, I am biased.