To answer Angie's question, no, I'm not willing to buy more colors to make this work. As it is, I'm trying to pare down the size of the wardrobe, so that wouldn't make sense. Maybe someday I will find a similar style in lime or apple green, colors I already have in my wardrobe. In another life, I'd keep this dress to wear to parties sans layers, but that is my fantasy life. :T
I'll still give the other dress a chance, though. That one is more of a turquoise and should look better with tan, rust, etc.
Vix, you know me! I really liked #1 a lot, esp. with the citron detail - I almost bought that one instead - but I wanted to stick to my guns about wanting a column of color to go well with my cropped jackets.