I like them much better cuffed slightly longer, and I think they are quite flattering that way. I wonder if a lot of the difference in opinion comes down to deep-seated views about BF jeans in general,. Some people simply don't like the look and never will, and there's nothing wrong with that. I have a poisoned eye for some looks, regardless of how much others like them, but BF jeans aren't one of those for me.
I am showing my age here (41), but I remember before there were BF cut jeans. In school, all the women's/girls jeans came up to my ribs and high-waisted was the norm. I and a number of my friends actually went out and bought men's jeans because we didn't want the waist so high. This became pretty popular, and manufacturers - assuming it was JUST a waist issue - started making low-rise women's jeans. They got lower to the point of obscenely low and they still weren't selling as well as they had expected. Women wanted what men's jeans offered - the slouchy, comfortable, lower-waisted kind of style. It took forever before manufacturers finally "got it" and actually started making jeans for women with that aesthetic in mind.
My point in my rambling here is that I was wearing men's jeans when I was 18, so the BF jean look is near and dear to me, and on you the Gap jeans nail the look, IMO. I vote to keep them.
