Amy, we are sweater twins, I have that one in navy (outfit 5 here and outfit 4 here).
I think it's a tricky thing though for the reason I haven't cracked yet. While I love it's chunky and has structure, almost like a soft jacket, and that it frames my neck (I like that), and I feel great in it, it just does not photograph well - my shoulders somehow disappear.
Looking at your outfit, I can tell something is not 100% to my eye and I'm trying to figure out whether it is the sweater-issue for you too. But I am still clueless.
Could it be the relation of the cardigan style and the neckline for certain body types? Or the way the bottom of the cardigan -- that nice rounded bit -- somehow spills over the hips, then the sleeves make that downward line even longer, which is why the whole silhouette looks odd.
No idea. But I wear mine and despite puzzling styling dilemmas I feel great in it. I hope you do too in yours because you look great in that colour.
ETA: I've just read all other comments. I'll try the scrunching trick next time too.
