I like this look. My eye was instantly attracted to the second from the left. That looks like a great weekend sweater. But if paired with nice pants and heels, do you think it could pass for smart-casual?

I just bought one of these in black at TJ Maxx by Marciano, and I love it!

oh i’ve been looking for one of these, great finds!

I’m so drawn to this look, but yet to try it on. Apprehensive about how it’ll look on my already-curvy bod! But since I definitely couldn’t get the boyfriend cardi working …

I have one in brown from Ann Taylor Loft-it is belted and I love it! You’re right- a good alternative to the boyfriend cardigan!

I found one buried in the back of an Old Navy Outlet clearance rack last spring, and was amazed at how great the rounded angle of the hem looked compared to the boxiness of a boyfriend cardigan. Mine is black and short-sleeved, so is trickier to wear in this frigid weather, but now I’m inspired to do some layering with it for tomorrow!

I wish I could find them in other colors and sleeve lengths. I’ll keep my eyes peeled now!

Angie, I was actually looking at the Frenchi sweater (second from the left). I like the V neck, the fact that it nips in at the waist, but was concerned about the possibility of it overemphasizing hips. What are your thoughts on this?

Great! I’m glad I’m not the only one who was pleasantly surprised with this silhouette.

Kyle, I had the same impression before I tried the style on and fitted it on others. The effect is extremely hourglass-y if you are pear shaped (when belted); and tends to add a bit of curve if you are straight. Loose, it’s boho chic and hides a multitude of sins in a flattering way – great for adorable apples. You have to try it on.

Christie, I’ve found this style works smart casually with a tailored button down worn underneath. If the knit is fine enough, I think you might have a smart casual look going sans the button down.

I’m not really wild about it, but then again, I didn’t like boyfriend cardis much either. My eye might need to adjust. I guess my concern might be about where it ends in the back and how it fits over a fullish bum.

i think the cut-away, albeit curved, of the hem is what makes it universally flattering.

i bought a classique (from nordie’s) open front shawl neck cardigan that i just started wearing over my tailored white button down. i feel so affirmed that angie approves of the look!!! it was a reach for me, definitely trying something new.

the boyfriend would never fit over the bustline, but i have faith that at some point i’ll have a cardi that does button/fasten over/under the bustline. i’ve recently realized that none of my cardigans fastened, and that bums me out that i have all the same style: open front. even a belted cardigan that is never belted is open front.

Maya, try on a version and experiment. I had the same impression as you and the style proved my initial impression wrong. Funny how that happens.

Bravo, Carissa. Your ensemble sounds great. Why can’t you find a cardigan that fastens in the front? I’m sure the forum members could help you out. Nicole could certainly help you out.

I have seen these curved hems on short shrugs, but have not noticed them on long cardis. I’ve tried several boyfriend cardis on and they made me look boxy, so did not buy any. I will try this and see if it’s more flattering. I like that gray one second from the left. Since knits tend to be less stable than wovens might the curved hem not lose its shape after a while? Particularly in the back, where it gets a lot of stretching from being sat on?

Like many others, I love the second one from the left. The combination of the button at the waist and the curvy hem make this 10 times more flattering than any boy friend cardi I’ve seen.

I bought two of them early in the season and returned both. The length wasn’t quite right and I just couldn’t pull it off. I got rid of my boyfriend cardigans too, all but one, because it’s just not a feminine look enough for me.