Thank you, all! Especially Angie, chiming in during a busy time! Angie, I was feeling the same way you did -- either a long jacket or going cropped seemed to work best to me. And of course, changing up the silhouette with BFs or straight jeans might yield some new looks too.
I did get a couple of compliments from strangers last night (including a "oh, I need to know where you got those jeans!") when I took a bit of a walk through the mall (right across the street from the radio station, such a danger zone, but I had a return to make at Nordstrom Rack). It's funny, I'm not seeing many flare jeans on other people yet, but people seem to be liking them on me. Maybe I'm ahead of the curve around here.
Thank you for the advice about hemming too. I'm going to hold off until I've worn and washed them once or twice. For now, they're my "high heels" flares. The Gap bootcuts will be my "low heel" jeans. That seems like a good solution.