Probably not with a "statement" piece. Maybe with a "basic"? Or with a perfectly fitting shoe? I'd be tempted, but...
To be honest, I'm really trying these days to stop duplicating because I inevitably end up wearing one to death and the other one sits in my closet much of the time. And, ultimately, I think I'd be better off with a variation of my favorite instead of an exact copy to keep me from falling into a style rut.
But, on the other hand, a rainbow of T's all stacked up neatly in my closet would look so appealing...