The pants in #2 are a smidgen bigger on me. I have the most serious pants problems. I've acquired at least two of practically all my pants. The smallest weight change, and the fit totally changes.
I like the idea of a button down, Lisa... I may even have a purple one that might go with that sweater. Don't have a white one, which seems crazy, doesn't it?
p.s. Angie - I'll have to tell my hair stylist you gave props to the cut! She'll be thrilled