Thanks for the feedback ladies, it's very helpful! It's always interesting to hear perceptions of outfits, especially so in cases where they feel one way but are seen another. I guess my skewing towards Team Polished helped me out with this one
Angie, I think I'm still a Countess or Baroness in the Sneakers Kingdom. Definitely still in training ^^
Claire, I love the idea of pairing with cognac for fall and would you believe I haven't really thought of that yet? All my pairings (well in my head, anyway) are with cream, black, and blue. Definitely adding cognac to the list, thanks!
Alana, the length is quite good on the culottes, especially a really wide pair like these; they just are generally meant to be worn with heels as I did last time I wore these, seen here. Flats can work, in particular lower-vamped footwear which is a much easier pairing. These are high-vamped but low contrast so it still works, but certainly not as flattering as a heeled shoe would be. If the culottes were slimmer I'd wear them a bit shorter.
Neel, to be honest I did feel a bit stumpy with the sneaks, low contrast and all! But it wasn't enough to diminish my happiness and I enjoyed the trendiness, so I left it.