I vote untucked too. I like the wider leg silhouette, I bought a pair of vintage Levi's for this exact reason. These tanks are also something I am thinking of adding to my summer wardrobe - maybe I can wear also in the office with a light jacket on, I don't know.
Great buys!

I like both and you could play around with a knotted shirt as well. I like the wide legged on you and think you’ll have a lot of fun with a different style.

KILLER new jeans!

And prefer the tank untucked too.