I think both look grood and the skinnies look good, and here's what's interesting to me: there's a color thing going on. The red skinnies with that shirt give you a monochromatic long look. I'm not saying you couldn't wear dark denim skinnies with the same outfit, I'm saying these may be the perfect combination and it really works. Also not just any monochrome but it's an attractive color as well. You can really see that in the photo and it goes to show us all, it's in the total package--fit, color, proportion--than whether we can or can't wear a particular style. You might find the red skinnies don't work as well with certain other tops and you might find the style groove in which you get the most wear out of them. So don't give them up! You might also find that "straight" (which to me seem skinny, LOL--who knew that was just getting started) is a better compromise, but I expect it will depend on the brand and fit, not what they're called.

I think we have similar self-concious areas. I have not done skinnies and flats (I do wear skinnies with boots in winter), and you in these red skinnies is making me want to give the look a try! Seriously, while I like the look of the bootcuts too, I think both look great and are flattering on you.
Someone gave you bright pink pants? That was a brave choice of gift!

Rachylou, that could be the reason!

Thanks Unfrumped! You're right of course, it's everything together. I actually thought I'd wear this shirt to keep the contrast low. Seems like it was working!

Thanks Jules! That's great to hear that I could inspire you to give it a try yourself. I got the pants from my stylish godmother. She always wants me to push my boundaries.... She's 60 years old and wears stuff a lot more fashionforward than me!