#1 & #2 are both great on you imo:)

Sorry the Vivians didn't work out for you. Definitely a shoe for high-volume feet.

(Incidentally, I requested the size exchange from Zappos midafternoon yesterday and had the new pair in my hot little hands around noon TODAY. Granted, Las Vegas isn't *that* far from the Bay Area, but I'm still astounded at how quick the turnaround was.)

Kelly, thanks so much for the PM. Your review was super helpful. I actually think the Sanita Vani might work on me. Just to be sure, it is adjustable in both places right? I just ordered some sandals that had buckles around the forefoot and they were purely decorative! What a waste of an excellent potential fit tool. Provided the fit can be adjusted both for narrow and wide feet.

ETA -- I don't mind the gearish vibe. And I look forward to your FIT FLOP review. Although I'm nervous that the unadjustable forefoot won't work on me.

Yes, Denise. They were both adjustable but only to make them bigger, IMHO. I couldn't make them tighter. It's so weird because I always think of my feet as on the wider side of average. I think this is the first time I haven't been able to fill out a sandal. Barking Dog Shoes reviewed the Vana too. Check out hers here http://www.barkingdogshoes.com.....eview.html

ETA: I had to order the FF through Nordies. Their shipping seems like a mule train compared to Zappos. I'll PM you when they get here. I tried the FF slide on at Norstrom today and the front was a little loose but I think the ankle strap will keep them in place. Good luck with the Vana:)

@Magpie: Zappos is amazing! What astounding service. Glad that they Vivians worked for you.