Loving everyone's responses here. Some "shadow styles" I would have guessed, and some I wouldn't have!
Denise, I may have originated the phrase but Vix actually had the idea, as well. She has three style personas and tries to satisfy all of them! Her boho side was sort of by way of being a bit of a shadow style for a while, I believe. And she's found ways to incorporate it into her actual life.
As for me, I'm not so sure I want to. I think my shadow style is really more about my fantasy self or fantasy life than it is about anything I truly want. Actually, now that I think of it, the closer I get to what I think of as my REAL style (whatever that is, LOL!) the less I'm attracted to my shadow style. Hmmm. Must mull that over some more!
Sarah, you caught the mood exactly! That's it!
Shannon, I can absolutely see you in K. Hepburn menswear inspired looks. They certainly satisfy the "retro" part of your rubric!
Kristin, that's what I was getting at—the style a part of you really likes, but just feels awkward.
Atlantia, I wonder if you WILL try it now? And what would happen?
Sveta and Claudia, I hear you on the body type/ proportions thing. A lot of times this gets in our way. I also find certain silhouettes very difficult, and if those are the "signature" silhouettes of a particular style (e.g. gamine) it might develop into a sort of shadow style. Believe it or not, anything with ballet flats sort of falls into that category for me. I have such trouble finding any that stay on. But I LOVE the look!
Vildy, so interesting to hear about your thinking on this! I am intrigued by the thought of a very (supposedly) practical shadow style. And then the recognition that NO...it just doesn't work!!
Mochi, I think shadow style might include those silhouettes that just don't work on one's body, but not necessarily. There are many things that don't work on my body and I couldn't care less; if I'm not attracted to the look, so what? Contrariwise, it's possible that some boho looks COULD work for my body type. There's no reason why not. But they somehow don't feel right on me anyway. They just don't feel like me. And yet the attraction would linger.
Texstyle, I hear you on this. I, too, am very attracted to certain professional or ladylike looks. TOO attracted. And yet if I wore them I would feel uptight. I've learned that for me, the high/low mix is essential. If my work didn't allow me some creative latitude in dressing I would end up feeling pretty miserable, I think. I'm not completely myself in a head-to-toe ladylike professional ensemble; but I'm not myself in a head-to-toe super casual look, either.
Scarlet, Helen...it sounds like "ladylike" is a shadow style for many. And Helen, you are right, Jung would have something to say about it.
Cciele, I should maybe study your WIW for inspiration about how to successfully incorporate my shadow!
Elly, your shadow styles make perfect sense, given the life situation you find yourself in!! Of course you would (with a part of yourself) crave drama and femininity.
Diana, I'll bet you COULD incorporate some elements of Mod style. But only if it felt good to you. And some of the lines might fight with other elements of your look. In the meantime, I think you absolutely have the "cool" quotient...just in a different way from the surfer girls.
Speaking of cool, Denise, you define it.
Isabel, I'd love to see you incorporate some UWP!! Can't wait! And I like your challenge, too.
Fern, another "ladylike" lawyer!
And Kiwi - a sexy bombshell!
Sarah, I think the embarrassment about admitting your shadow shows it's a TRUE shadow!!
Mo, I think I actually see elements of both the flowy romantic and the studded (well, zippered, LOL) in your actual wardrobe. So maybe your shadows are already well incorporated into your overall look!
Joy, great suggestion for incorporating a bit of boho (if I still want to, which I'm not sure I do after going through all this, LOL!)
CHristianne, high five - another boho wannabe! (and ladylike wannabe, too!)
Thanks, all, for weighing in and helping me think it through.