I scooped up some light gray booties after Christmas (and went back and got a price adjustment after New Year's, go me). Literally the only option in the department stores that didn't have a RATE, Western, or biker feel, and they're perfect.

But they're not Aquatalia's, so I really need to spray them with something before I wear them much more. There are just enough options on Amazon that I'm nervous about ordering them. I doubt whatever I choose will go Horribly Wrong. But I also figured it wouldn't hurt to ask for personal experiences.