I posted this dress under another thread, but I was happy to have the chance to try them both on. Both are nice, but I'm not getting either right now. I tried lighter weight short sleeve and 3/4 sleeve tops too, but will look more earnestly in early spring. The sweater reminds me that wool isn't a great fabric for me to wear (although it didn't feel see through, as others have mentioned). I really like the sweater color.
Note - it's been mid 80s for temps here, so I'm trying to buy according to what will actually get worn.
Props to Angie - it was her descriptions that made me think they would work for my body type.