I got the Madewell black jackets I ordered but unfortunately both sizes went back. Neither felt like a good fit, mainly because the arm holes were restrictive and that's a deal-killer for me. Irregardless of that, the size 8 swallowed me. About 4" too big around, sleeves way too long, and jacket way too long. The size 6 was better length-wise but again, it hit me, mid-thigh. They just didn't feel right and when I asked my husband what he thought, he said "Mmmm.. well...they make you look a little....larger." I couldn't pack them fast enough after that, haha.

I'm 5'3" and weight about 135 so I don't need anything that makes me look a little...mmmm...larger.