JAileen, I haven't seen the Vince in person. I have to order it and see for myself. I can't order it for a few weeks though. I have to wait until September 26th because of a no spend agreement with my daughter.
Deb, do you mean the J Crew turtle neck in the henna melange color? That's a nice sweater. I tried one on in size small and the shoulders didn't fit right. I may have to try the medium. It's fairly classic in terms of design and I already have 4 classic turtleneck sweaters. I am looking for something with a little more design interest, even if it is a simple effect like longer looser fit, or the herringbone pattern in the Vince sweater.
Angie, I also love turtle necks, but have a hard time finding them with a fit that I like. I clearly have the long neck that goes well with wearing this neckline! It appears that they make the equipment turtleneck in a heather gray. I wonder if that color would be good? It looks like a medium gray, and not as light as the Vince.