Thank you, Mirjana, Star, Xtabay, and Zaeobi, for your assessments. Zaeobi, yes, the tee is self-made.
kkards, well put. I have had the same experience.
Gail, I hear you. I like being able to try on things, especially pants. Even with stores nearby, I often find they don't have what I've been eyeing online. I wanted to try the straight leg cords, but the store didn't have them.
Janet, it's true. I don't like the feel of a tight waistband, either, and when a sales associate tells me to size down, I rarely agree with the recommendation. I will try these on again today.
Angie, my thought, too, was that these could be a different look and fit than my usual roomier ones. I like the 70s vibe of them. But I do need to see how they feel around home and what I might wear them with.
Roberta, that's exactly my problem with Madewell: rises that are too high. Now they are offering some lower ones, but only in a few denims. I often find colors that I love at Madewell, so it's super disappointing not to find the right fit.
Style Fan, these are right up your alley, style-wise, but I agree the color isn't quite right.