I am actually contemplating buying another pair of the CoH Huttons, next size up, and having the flare tamed a bit by the tailor.
I do like the BR trouser jeans I just got yesterday but ....I am afraid I just don't love them. They are serviceable but yeah... IK... I am with you here. Once you go premium it is really really hard to go back.
It's weird though... I tried on a BR trouser jean that had tapered leg at the store, more like a skinny... and the denim was different, it was lighter than these I just got in the mail. I prefer the lighter weight denim. The CoH Huttons are lighter weight too. I just think they flow and drape better, and look and feel more trousery.
Then again if I just gave up chips for Lent I could drop a couple of pounds and be back in the jeans already in my dresser drawer! *sigh*