Carter, can you please do a post that gives us all lessons in how to put together this amazing collage?? It is brilliant! And --- um -- so is your wardrobe! I want to come play in your closet. You have some great items with a lovely "colour story" as you called it -- and the new footwear looks sensational.
I don't actually have a ton of footwear -- although compared to my pre-YLF days, when I literally had one pair of shoes, one pair of sandals, and one pair of boots, my closet it overflowing.
But if I had to replace it all immediately -- I would probably cry like crazy! I love my (currently unwearable due to the snow) booties.
I would be in serious trouble if I had to switch to flats. They don't stay on my feet. Like, NONE of them. Unless they have laces, that is. Talk about needing my toes to grip!! That is my life in any kind of pump or loafer, and all the more so in one that is flat.
So these recommendations MUST vary according to the type of foot a person has. At least I hope so. If they told me to get rid of my current shoes and switch to flats I would be limited to sneakers or oxfords.