Great top and great combos with the various pants. The one you might avoid is #2, with the longest jeans. The summery, breezy top goes better with the crops and shorts, IMO. Keep.

I was ambivalent yesterday so I didn't post, but... Even with the new pics, something about the gathered shoulder bugs me for you. I wonder if this is one of those tops that looks bad in pictures and much better in person.

I'm with Firecracker on this. It's not too Boho, and I like it. Keep!

As another boho fan, I love this top. It looks great on you! I'm surprised by how much I love the semi-tuck (I rarely think to do that with my flowy blouses), and I plan to try this soon! I love your looks with cropped pants and belt most!

Super cut top, definitely a keeper I think! I like it semi tucked, preferably with a belt, but either way works!

I really like it with the shorts and the salmon(?) crops. With the flower belt. Very nice!

I hear you, Laura. I don't disagree that poufy, gathered things are not me. I like clean and simple. However, I am seriously trying to loosen up a bit;-) I should add that I feel this way about asymmetry too, but I have bought a couple tops with asymmetric hems and am starting to kind of like them. I'll be living at the beach in a year or so, so battling the type A, anal retentive thing is a long, slow process!

Thanks so much everyone for giving me ideas how to wear this top. My husband really thinks it's great, so it will definitely see some date nights!