I have a slim silver Movado watch that I have worn exclusively for 2 years now. I had a white chunky watch over the summer that I really enjoyed wearing, and now I'd like a chunkier watch to wear in winter/fall. First I fell for gold, then my mom got a rose gold watch and I lusted after it for a bit, and now I am sort of really liking tortoise shell

Here's the deal:
1) I need to pick ONE.
2) I need to avoid Michael Kors prices.

Which one would you think would get more use? And is there such thing as a cheap alternative to MK that doesn't look cheap?