IK - that is a very interesting point and I am pondering it. I think, in my personal reference frame, cardigan pertains to the third finish piece (a la Imogen) that can be but is not always dressy. Wool, silk, cotton. I do have a long sweatshirt zip hoodie - it must be 36" in length and, as you say, it could be called a cardigan. But in my mind this is gear and remains a long sweatshirt hoodie. So I totally see and agree with your point, but in sorting my closet it seems I am a splitter, rather than a lumper, for the sake of clarity and utility. If that makes sense. But I am with you in that we do not need a new moniker for every piece of clothing!! But you really gave me pause, in a good way, and made me contemplate how I do use labels, in my mind, to denote use and construction. Thanks so much for chiming in. Very interesting thoughts and discussion!!
Vipanchi - I think that is just how this is meant to be constructed, controlled volume. I think it will depend on sizing and body type to see if the fit is flattering. A number of reviews did mention the sleeves are snug on the smaller size but I agree that would make the silhouette more flattering.