MsMaven, thanks for the compliment on the dress. I didn't know this brand before seeing some pretty dresses on Nordstrom and then of course from Angie's reccomendation. It will be a go-to brand for me moving forward.
Stephanie, thanks. I am open to gold and just remembered I do have a small gold clutch I could use. The only problem is (and I forgot to mention this before) - I usually struggle with ankle strap shoes. by the time I get the shoe big enough to have the ankle strap fit, my foot is flopping around. I think it is bc I have larger ankles. I won't rule them out, but probably prefer a pump or sandal with more straps around the top of the foot.
Suz, I really should try some Okalas. I will check pricing. I just have it in my head that the ankle strap won't work (see comment above) but they're worth a try since they work so well for so many here on YLF. Will check your ebay link too
Angie, thank you again. I really can't say enough about the dress. I promise to post pics. I agree, I like the metallic shoe and bag combo idea. Thanks again!
tammyw, I am trying for the ultimate combo - as cheap as I can get, but as comfy as I can get. I know, the two don't go together, haha. Problem is, I don't have many if any events like this to attend, so I hate to shell out so much money for a pair of shoes I will wear once.
Elle, you have a valid point - one DH made, too.
I also know this shoe will work for me (naturalizer in find 1 below), I have it in black and could get it in silver or gold. I would have a chance of rewearing these (and the Okalas too, if they worked). Pro is the lightly chunkier heel, to Elly's point re outdoor walking (and toddler wrangling, haha).
Another option is in Find 2 - this type of strap works on my foot. Good price, too, and it is 4.5 in with a 3/4in platform.
I've gone full circle, from thinking the Naturalizer silver sandal was it, to thinking I needed a pointy toe, then realizing ankle straps are difficult to fit for me, so back to sandals.
I could likely rewear the Okalas and the sandals, the rest would likely sit unworn, sadly, so I would want to spend the least possible.
I'm thinking maybe I just need to try some on but I get antsy and want it solved NOW - my personality, ugh.
Anyway - thanks to all for your input!!