Talk to me about your Rothy's - YouLookFab Forum

Category

Shopping

Welcome! Read about what to wear and how to wear it on the YLF Blog. Join the YLF Forum to ask specific questions or just chat about fashion and personal style. Or check out the curated list of things we love in YLF Finds.

Outfits Ensembles Trends Advice

Talk to me about your Rothy's

Murph11

Veteran

I'm intrigued by these upcycled slip-ons as an alternative to sneakers (which I'm just not reaching for). For me, they would be "running errand" shoes and not necessarily 10,000 step shoes.

Can anyone shed light on their comfort or durability? Are they worth US$165?

I'm assuming I'd need to add an insole (since they include the option for a pair at check-out). I'd likely order the 10 and 10.5 to compare since the reviews are all over the place regarding fit (yet 4- and 5-star reviews).

https://rothys.com/womens/loafers

Thank you for any insight!

This post has 1 photo. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

Shopping

18 replies

Latest reply was from Mainelady

Christina F.

Veteran

I'm curious about these too. I can't wear them, mind you. Too flat. But I see so many folks complain about the price on their Facebook ads, thinking that recycled materials should cost less. NOPE. Big misconception, there, as they do indeed cost more.

viva

Veteran

I tried the pointy toe but returned them - they just squished my toes too much, and a larger size would have flopped off my foot. But I have a friend who has a pair of the round toe and swears by them.

nancylee

Veteran

I own a pair of the pointy toe flats. For me, they've been comfortable--they actually have some stretch to them--although some might consider them "pinchy." You'd probably be safe with a loafer or more rounded toe. Mostly, I wear them for running around in town, but I did wear them for a day of sightseeing in San Francisco and felt fine. They wash up nicely as advertised, which is pretty amazing.

I agree that they're too expensive, but if you sleuth around on the internet you might be able to find a discount code for 20%. That's what I did...clicked through a fashion blog that offered a review and a discount link.

texasgal

I have 5 pair (!)- 3 pointy toe flats (red, black, and grey tweed), a pair of navy loafers, and a pair of white slip-on sneakers. They are very comfortable- I walked 5 miles in them in NYC without any problems. They also machine wash really well. I always take a pair travelling- they are very light weight and look great with my dressy pants. I just got back from a surgical conference and saw a ton of the female surgeons wearing them (with pants and dresses). They are definitely worth the $ for me.

UmmLila (Lisa)

Veteran

I have two pairs of the pointy-toe flats. Well, I actually just passed the lavender pair on to my daughter. I get compliments on them every time I wear them, and I have a slight wish for the red camo ones, but IMO they are not really worth the money unless you want vegan shoes made of sustainable material.

hereforthecake

It's painful to try to get them in Canada, so I'm awaiting the day that changes!

Anonymous

I’m interested too , and sorry to hear that getting them here in Canada is difficult . It *is*a lot of $ for a fabric shoe but if they are as great as they seem........ I’d be down for a pair .

Murph11

Veteran

Thanks for all your Rothy’s info!

Texasgal— 5 pair, that’s a testament right there!
UL— love the red camo too!

My feet want open-air ALL summer, but will likely order a pair in August — unless I find a pair or two of fab flats at NAS in July. Definite wardrobe hole!

Anonymous

There's always a big markup on goods made of recycled materials, though the price doesn't seem extreme per se. But-would you wear them enough to justify them?

Mainelady

Veteran

I have 3 pairs of pointy toe flats and I love them! I walk in them all day and my feet are happy. They offer comfort, but not a lot of arch support. Rothy’s are expensive, but then again, most of the shoes I wear are. I like that they are washable. I don’t worry about them getting dirty so I wear them when walking my dogs and while on playground duty. Other shoes I own need to be changed before those activities. If you are on Rothy’s mailing list, you will be notified when they decide to discontinue colors.....those are on sale.

Murph11

Veteran

Suntiger, comfort is the question! I have very low tolerance for shoes that pinch, rub or not cushioned. I will pay this and some for shoes that I’ll reach for over and over. And, I like the look of them!

Mainelady, I was hoping you’d chime in! Thank you for your review. I love that they’re washable. Do you purchase the extra insoles?

Sounds like they’re worth ordering. Thanks!

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

I have clients that SWEAR by them, and I see lots in them on the streets of Seattle and Salt Lake City. I think they're worth a try.

Anonymous

I think I'll dive in and order a pair too.

Gretchen

Veteran

I"m another fan - have the points in Red Camo and Grey Zebra. I love them for travel, and being able to throw them in the wash is a huge plus.

FWIW - I was not a fan of the rounded toe flat. I ordered in Red to try out, and looked like Ronald McDonald shoes!

Alexandra

(website)

Veteran

I have the loafers in black and love them. They’re my work-with-everything shoes. I put heel cups under the insoles that came with them to avoid rubbing. The shoes work perfectly in low humidity. But when it’s warm and humid, they feel like I’m wearing Saran wrap, so beware.

Murph11

Veteran

Even more good feedback! Thank you!

Angie, I’ve never seen anyone wearing them ( then again, I need to leave the house more)! Lisa p: we’ll both give them a try. Thanks, Gretchen and Alexandra for your reviews. I think I’ll order the points too for comparison.

ClaraT

Veteran

TL/DR: I think they would be good for you since you are looking for running errand shoes and not walk-all-day shoes.

Here are my detailed thoughts: I debated Rothys for months--I have fairly severe bunions, and I've never found a ballet flat that can accommodate my wide forefoot and narrow/normal heel. Most ballet flats are so painful that I cannot walk more than a couple of steps in them. I've never owned a pair in my life.

Lo and behold, I was gifted a pair of Rothys recently ("The Flat" style; white, grey and black camo pattern) and...they are great!

The size 8 "Flat" style fit my 7.5/8 feet very well with *no pain* in the toe area. The back of one rubbed a bit, but after 3 days of full time wear (for reasons I won't go into), it no longer rubs. The camo pattern goes with my usual bottoms (black ponte, white jeans, dark jeans). The shoes are adorable and disguise my distressingly unattractive bunions.

I subsequently purchased "The Point" in camo red. They are adorable and surprisingly versatile. I sized up to an 8.5 and they are comfortable and stay on my feet (so: 8 in The Flat and 8.5 in The Point).

The Rothys don't feel very supportive (I think an insole would help--I just have the insole that came with the shoes), but somehow my feet (and back) just don't hurt, and I've walked all over the place (no hills). Sneakers and booties are more padded and more comfortable.

So, thumbs up (way up) from me.

When you buy a pair, they give you a code. Mine is ADHFQ2W. I think if you use that, you save $20 and they give a discount off my next pair (if I buy another). So use that if you like...and hope this helps.

Mainelady

Veteran

I have not ordered extra insoles. The ones that come with the shoes are removable. I wash those more frequently than the shoes. So far they are holding up well. My oldest pair of Rothy’s are just over a year old. They get a lot of wear.