I have lots of chemical sensitivities so I stick to Clinique. I have very pale coloring including lips and recently I’ve preferred light, bright colors. I wear the Clinique Chubby Stick in mighty mimosa - often just a quick streak of it like lipgloss before I mush my lips together, rather than a full lip. For nighttime sometimes I wear Clinique All Heart. It’s a nice subtle color.
Love the suggestions here especially since our coloring is similar.
I will check out the Mineral Fusion pencils although I’m sensitive to something their lotion (titanium dioxide seems to be one of the things that bothers me, which is frustrating and dumb as it’s in everything and generally innocuous.)