So I ordered the LD Tuttle Remove sandal booties - the same ones Anna has but in grey - from Shoescribe. They were on super sale. UPS said they delivered the package Monday but the box was nowhere to be seen.
I've never had a package stolen before, but that's what must have happened. I'll call UPS tomorrow to make sure there's not some other explanation. They didn't take the signed delivery slip (their first attempt was Friday, and I left the slip there Monday) so it's possible they didn't actually deliver them.
And to add to the plot... the exact same boots, new in box, from Shoescribe, just appeared on Ebay Tuesday. From a seller with no feedback who's one town south of me. I can't help but think those might be the boots stolen from my steps.
I'm sure there are practical steps I can take - maybe I can talk to ebay? Or shoescribe to see if they delivered the same boots to that town recently? And maybe I can find a way to have future packages delivered somewhere else, like work. But mostly I'm just really sad and upset at losing $200. Plus, I was considering wearing them as a bridesmaid this weekend.
A happy update: Shoescribe gave me a full refund after investigating it with UPS! I wish I'd known that was standard procedure - I'd have saved myself a bit of stress and worry. The suspicious shoes are still on Ebay but I don't think I'll bid on them!