I've been on a bit of a shoe buying binge lately and thought I'd share my finds, in hopes that they'll help others with low-volume feet.
The Sofft Bernia: I bought this one in my regular size 10 before it showed up on Angie's recommendation list. My feet slopped around terribly and I was all set to send it back to Zappos and move onto something new. When Angie suggested sizing down, I decided to try that since I liked the shoe overall. Lo and behold, a 9.5 works. It's nice and snug over the top of the foot, and I still seem to have enough room in the toe.
The Cobb Hill Aubrey: These are more vintage-looking than I usually go for, but I fell in love with the teal color. I bought my regular size 10 in a narrow and probably could've gotten away with the medium, too, thanks to the T and ankle-strap combination. Most importantly, these are nicely padded and are sweet relief for my bony, high-arched feet. Would highly recommend!