I just bought the exact same pair! I've only tested them around the house so far, but for 3.5" heels I find they are pretty comfortable. I specifically wanted some heels since I have none and I like the way they look with tucked in jeans. I do find they make my feet look a bit big too, but then again I have size 8.5 feet on a fairly small body, so it's not like I can hid them! I want to post some pics of them soon to see what others think.